I’ve been asking myself in the last few days if I should hire a writing coach. Not because I can’t write, but because I think I can probably write even better.
The other reason I’m thinking about it is that I think I’ve got a really good story cooking and I don’t want to waste it. I’m still on the fence, but I thought I’d do a pre New Years resolution post on what to look for in a coach.
1. Are they a published author/editor/agent or someone who is qualified to advise you?
A coach isn’t a beta reader, or a helpful friend, or even a fellow writer you found as part of a writing group. A writing coach is someone you are paying to help you achieve results. A writing coach has one goal. Help you get published.
Not help you get better, a writing teacher/beta reader can help with that. If you’re going to go so far as to hire a coach, then you need someone who has either been there themselves, or is so involved in the industry that they know what they’re doing.
2. Are they successful?
A lot of writers and the like make extra money by selling training services and seminars. That’s a great way for any writer to make ends meet, but you can and should expect your coach to have achieved some degree of success in writing fiction themselves. Obviously you want to do more than be an author who sold four books and bankrupted a small press. Of course not many best selling authors offer coaching (although some do), but you should check a teacher’s references and achievements.
3. Are they a good teacher?
This is one of the most important questions you can ask about a coach; can they teach? Not every great writer is a great teacher of writing. The same is true in sport. A lot of great athletes can’t teach others how to do what they do, they just do it. The best martial arts coach I ever had wasn’t the most successful fighter in the gym, he just knew exactly how to teach me what I needed to know. He could tell me, without judgement, when I was getting things wrong, and he told me without hyperbole when I was getting it right. He also cracked a lot of jokes, that’s not a necessity, but it does make any criticism easier to take.
A writing coach should be able to do all of these things for you. If your story is really, really bad, a coach is being paid to tell you why it’s bad and how to fix it. If they can’t do that, what are you paying them for?
Things to remember:
- A coach doesn’t necessarily look at your whole manuscript. They may just look at an outline and pitch for your story. Obviously it’s better if they can look at the whole thing, but it’s not vital.
- A coach can’t write your story for you. The normal rules about having an original, well written story still apply.
- Try and fix all typos and make your story as good as it can get before your coach sees it. The better your story is when they see it, the more they can help you.
- If your coach gives you advice, and you don’t take that advice, that’s your choice… but if you then subsequently fail to be published, it’s not your coach’s responsibility, it’s yours.
- If you take your coach’s advice, and you still don’t get published, it may not be your coach’s fault; however you should reassess their advice. If it was good advice, and your book still didn’t get picked up, then it may just be a matter of pitching more agents and publishers until you get a hit.
A good example:
Larry Brooks, over at www.storyfix.com meets all of my criteria (and more). I haven’t actually used the coaching service, but I know from reviewing his other work that he knows how to teach, has achieved a high degree of success writing fiction and is qualified to teach you how to write.
I know I pimp Larry’s stuff a lot, but that’s because he’s really good, and he’s the person I’ll probably go with if I get myself a coach. With that said there other coaches out there, do your research, talk to the coaches involved and make your decision from there.
Happy New Year everyone, thanks for visiting me and listening to me ramble. Here’s looking forward to an epic 2010.
Tags: advice, coaching, writing